The Rhondda Chronicle newspaper of the time describes how, 'After only a few years immunity from the devastation of colliery explosions, the Rhondda has once more become the centre of very sorrowful and melancholy interest'. It goes on to describe how, ‘the Angel of Death had been at his dread task mowing down the colliers who were finishing their nights work in the Tylorstown colliery'. The report also details the thousands of people from Merthyr, Aberdare and Rhondda Valleys who congregated at the pit-head to wait anxiously for news of those ‘entombed in the dark depths of the mine'. The newspaper also describes the ‘considerable' number of funerals and the large attendances accompanying them, both in the burial grounds of the district (Llethrddu Cemetery, Maerdy Cemetery and Llanwonno Churchyard) and also those bodies taken away by train for burial in Aberystwyth, St Clears, Cheltenham and Welshpool.
The explosion at Tylorstown took place at approximately 5.30 am, a time when most of the night shift had ascended to the surface at the end of their shift and before the day shift descended into the mine. Thus the eventual death toll of 57 would have been much greater if the explosion had taken place at a time when a full shift, which consisted of over 300 men, was working below ground.
An inquest into the explosion took place between 18 and 25 February and the jury returned the verdict, ‘…the cause of the explosion was the firing of a shot in gas in Daniel Williams’ stall in No.8 pit and that the air passing through the faces was charged with gas… and the explosion was accelerated by coal dust. Also that no one now living was responsible for the explosion'.
Additionally, Robert Woodfall and J.T. Robson, Inspector of Mines for the South Wales district, wrote a Report into the explosion. They described the mine, owned by D. Davies and Sons Ltd. (part of the Ferndale Coal Company), as dry and dusty and criticised the effectiveness of the watering of the mine. The mine was also described as ‘fiery' necessitating a locked lamps policy with no naked flames except at lamp stations, and no shot firing being allowed during a shift. There was frequent presence of gas in the mines, however no standing gas was left to accumulate. In fact, gas had been detected and dispersed from Daniel Williams’ stall, where the explosion of 27 January was thought to have originated, as recently as 10 January. The Inspectors in their report concluded that the cause of the explosion was the fault of a fireman who had fired a shot in Daniel Williams’ stall negligently, as he should have been aware of the presence of gas in the stall and immediate vicinity.